Executive Summary

• The S&P/TSX Capped Consumer Staples Index materially outperformed the broader TSX during recent volatility
• Staples benefited from:
  • defensive rotation
  • stable cash-flow expectations
  • consumer trade-down behaviour
• Key leaders included:
  • Loblaw Companies Limited
  • Empire Company Limited
  • Metro Inc.
• The sector acted as a “defensive shelter” while discretionary and industrial names weakened
• Performance has been steady rather than explosive — classic low-volatility leadership

---

TSX Consumer Staples Capped Index (TTCS)

Metric	Approx. Recent Trend
Sector Bias	Defensive / Positive
Volatility	Lower than TSX
Relative Performance	Outperformed broader TSX during risk-off days
Main Drivers	Grocery stability + defensive rotation

S&P/TSX Capped Consumer Staples Index

---

Main Components of TTCS

Company	Weighting Influence
Loblaw Companies Limited	Very High
Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc.	Very High
Metro Inc.	High
Empire Company Limited	Moderate
George Weston Limited	Moderate

---

Why TTCS Has Been Relatively Strong

1) Defensive Rotation (largest driver)

Investors rotated into staples because:

• economic growth uncertainty increased
• oil prices rose sharply
• geopolitical risk increased

Staples historically outperform when markets become defensive because:

• food demand is stable
• revenues are predictable
• margins are less cyclical

---

2) Canadian Consumer Trade-Down

Higher living costs caused consumers to:

• spend less on discretionary goods
• focus more on essentials
• shop discount/value channels

This benefited:

• grocery chains
• discount food retail
• convenience retail

Especially:

• Loblaw Companies Limited
• Metro Inc.

---

3) Stable Earnings Visibility

Compared with cyclical sectors:

• staples earnings are more predictable

Investors rewarded:

• strong free cash flow
• stable dividends
• pricing power

This became important as:

• TSX discretionary stocks weakened
• industrial earnings became less certain

---

4) Oil Prices Helped Convenience Retail

Higher fuel prices can actually help:

• fuel-margin operators
• convenience chains

That supported:

• Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc.

Although ATD has recently shown volatility tied to valuation and acquisition concerns, the defensive nature of the business remains supportive.

---

Relative Performance vs Other TSX Sectors

Sector	Recent Relative Strength
Energy	Strongest
Consumer Staples (TTCS)	Strong
Materials	Moderate
Financials	Mixed
Industrials	Weak/Mixed
Consumer Discretionary (TTCD)	Weaker
Technology	Volatile

---

Key Characteristics of TTCS

Feature	Interpretation
Lower beta	Less volatile
Dividend support	Defensive yield
Stable demand	Recession-resistant
Slower growth	Lower upside in bull markets
Strong pricing power	Helps offset inflation

---

Valuation Logic

Recent strength in TTCS was driven mainly by:

• defensive positioning
• earnings stability
• cash-flow visibility

Not driven by:

• rapid revenue acceleration
• speculative growth
• AI/technology enthusiasm

---

Risks to TTCS

Risk	Potential Impact
Consumer weakness deepens	Margin pressure
Food inflation slows sharply	Revenue normalization
Interest rates remain high	Valuation pressure
Rotation back into cyclicals	Relative underperformance
Regulatory/grocery pricing scrutiny	Margin concerns

---

Bull / Base / Bear Outlook

Bull

• Economic uncertainty persists
• Staples continue outperforming
• Investors favor defensives

Base

• Sector remains stable but underwhelming
• Modest dividend-driven returns

Bear

• Strong economic rebound
• Capital rotates into cyclicals/tech
• Staples lag materially

---

What Would Disprove the Defensive Thesis

• Staples underperform during market volatility
• Grocery margins compress materially
• Consumers shift back aggressively toward discretionary spending
• Economic growth accelerates sharply

---

Actionable Takeaways

• TTCS is behaving exactly as expected in a:
  • higher-volatility
  • inflation-sensitive
  • uncertain macro environment
• Leadership is being driven by:
  • earnings stability
  • predictable cash flow
  • defensive investor positioning
• Watch:
  • grocery inflation trends
  • consumer spending patterns
  • fuel margins
  • Bank of Canada policy direction